EGYPT: Augustinos Samaan loses appeal against five-year sentence

Augustinos SamaanOn 15 November Egypt’s Court of Cassation rejected the legal challenge filed by Coptic Christian scholar Dr Augustinos Samaan against his five-year prison sentence with hard labour for “contempt of religion”.

Coptic Solidarity commented, “The ruling leaves the conviction in force despite serious legal and constitutional irregularities documented by his defence team” and went on to state that the case “reinforces concerns about the use of Egypt’s blasphemy legislation to restrict the ability of Christians to explain and defend their own religious beliefs, particularly when doing so involves questioning or criticising Islamic teachings”.

Augustinos (37) holds a PhD in comparative religion and has been in detention since October 2025 for posting apologetics videos on a YouTube channel with over 100,000 subscribers in which he answered questions about Christianity, examined theological and philosophical differences between Christianity and Islam and responded to anti-Christian arguments.

Augustinos was convicted at a secret trial in January 2026 on charges of “contempt of religion” and “misuse of social media” under Article 98(f) of the Egyptian Penal Code, often referred to as Egypt’s blasphemy law, which deals with contempt of religion offences and criminalises speech deemed offensive to Islam. A sentence of five years’ imprisonment with hard labour was handed down by the El-Basatin Misdemeanour Court on 3 January.

The Misdemeanour Appeals Court upheld his sentence on 23 February, following an initial appeal, and on 24 April Augustinos filed an appeal with the Cassation Court.

The Cassation Court examined his appeal but did not accept the legal grounds advanced by the defence as sufficient to overturn the judgment. Augustinos’ lawyers stated that pending the publication of the Court’s written reasoning they will examine if there is any remaining legal avenue available beyond the cassation challenge.

Serious procedural violations

Augustinos’ defence team had previously highlighted several serious procedural violations surrounding his conviction. His lawyers and family were not notified that his case had been referred to trial and they arrived at court on 6 January expecting a routine detention-renewal hearing only to find that he had already been tried and sentenced. In addition, the defence team was denied timely access to essential case documents, depriving it of the ability to represent Augustinos before his conviction.

The defence challenged the authenticity of the official arrest report, which was dated a week after the arrest, and also challenged the legality of the security authorities’ monitoring and examination of Augustinos’ social media accounts without prior authorisation by the prosecution. 

Background

Augustinos was arrested in the early hours of 1 October 2025 by masked special-forces officers who confiscated his laptop, phone, books and personal papers.

Following interrogation and reported torture he was initially charged with terrorism-related offences, but prosecutors later dropped these charges and instead charged him with “contempt of religion” and misuse of social media.

From October to December 2025 Augustinos was held in pretrial detention in El Basatin police station alongside detainees accused of serious criminal offences, and reportedly suffered mistreatment and abuse. Detention was repeatedly renewed in 15-day increments until his trial took place.

Coptic Solidarity notes that there are serious concerns regarding Augustinos’ physical and mental well-being in detention, following reports of torture, humiliation and abuse by other detainees.

The rights organisation points out that Augustinos’ case raises “two fundamental and closely interconnected issues: the criminalisation of peaceful religious expression and the denial of basic fair-trial guarantees”.

Egypt’s Constitution guarantees freedom of belief and the right to a fair trial and legal defence and Egypt is a party to the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which protects fair-trial rights and freedom of religion, belief and expression.

(ADF International, Coptic Solidarity)

Photo: ADF International